Gomme Lisce Mark V o Xiom Musa?

Premesso che ho intenzione di fare un downgrade su un telaio semirigido usando delle gomme non pretensionate,
Sono indeciso tra le due gomme in oggetto.
Chi può aiutarmi nella scelta, specificando che il mio stile di gioco è classificabile ALL+ / OFF-
Grazie in anticipo.

 

La musa è di una qualità nettamente superiore rispetto alla Mark5, oltre ad essere più nuova e quindi più adatta al gioco moderno.

 

Concordo in pieno

 

Mi permetto di intervenire perchè queste sono due gomme che conosco molto bene,avendole usate a lungo, lisce e gasate entrambe.Non penso che la Musa sia migliore della Mark V, solo diversa.E' definibile come una Vega non tensionata( ho usato anche questa) per l'ottimo grip e la medio-buona velocità,che diventa decisamente buona se boosterata.Più dura della Mark V, compensa il minor impegno della spugna con un
elevato grip di superficie, che permette ci caricare la palla anche con movimenti brevi ma rapidi.La Yasaka
è una gomma classica, con buone-ottime prestazioni in tutti i reparti senza gravi lacune, come le altre storiche gomme Coppa e Sriver.Rimane attualmente la gomma non tensionata più venduta in Giappone,
ed una delle più vendute in assoluto.Sta a te decidere se preferisci più grip e controllo (la Musa) o più
velocità e reattività(la Mark V).Spero di esserti stato utile. Saluti

 

Grazie Tigrepong62. Sei stato molto chiaro nella tua analisi

 

E rispetto alle Donic Coppa? Sapresti farci un confronto?

 

Comparison among table tennis rubber: Yasak Mark V, Donic Coppa, Xiom Musa. Which are the charactersits and which is more suitable for a all round player?

Let’s compare the **Yasaka Mark V**, **Donic Coppa**, and **Xiom Musa** table tennis rubbers, focusing on their characteristics and suitability for an all-round playing style.

### 1. **Yasaka Mark V**

**Overview**:
- One of the most famous and classic rubbers in table tennis, Yasaka **Mark V** has been around for decades and is known for its all-round characteristics. It offers a great balance of speed, spin, and control, making it suitable for players of various skill levels.

**Characteristics**:
- **Speed**: Medium-fast. While not as fast as modern tensors, Mark V offers adequate speed for offensive and all-round players.
- **Spin**: Good, but not extremely high compared to newer rubbers with tackier topsheets or tensors. It still allows for solid topspin play.
- **Control**: Excellent. Its forgiving nature makes it great for consistent play and controlled strokes, which is a key factor for all-round players.
- **Hardness**: Medium-hard sponge (around 45°), which gives a good balance of power and control.

**Playing Style**:
- Suited for **all-round players** who prefer a balance between offense and defense. Mark V excels in controlled spin, block, and counter-attacks, making it a great rubber for consistent play close to the table.

---

### 2. **Donic Coppa**

**Overview**:
- Donic **Coppa** is another classic rubber, but it has a slightly more offensive character compared to Mark V. It is part of the earlier generation of tensor rubbers, so it’s faster and livelier but still offers good control.

**Characteristics**:
- **Speed**: Faster than Mark V, due to its tensor technology. It is suitable for offensive play, but it’s not as fast as more modern tensors.
- **Spin**: Offers good spin for loopers, especially for fast, offensive strokes. The topsheet allows decent grip, but it’s not as spinny as newer rubbers designed for high-level topspin play.
- **Control**: Still offers decent control despite its increased speed. It’s not as forgiving as Mark V but more suitable for players who want to transition to a more offensive game.
- **Hardness**: Medium sponge (around 43°), slightly softer than Mark V, which makes it easier to generate spin while maintaining a degree of control.

**Playing Style**:
- Best suited for **offensive players** who want a slightly faster rubber but still require a decent level of control. It’s a good option for an all-round player leaning toward more aggressive play.

---

### 3. **Xiom Musa**

**Overview**:
- **Xiom Musa** is a modern non-tensor rubber aimed at providing a high level of control with enough speed and spin to suit an all-round or control-oriented game. It's popular among players who prefer non-tensor rubbers for better consistency.

**Characteristics**:
- **Speed**: Slower than Donic Coppa and Yasaka Mark V. Musa is designed for players who prioritize control over speed. It’s well-suited for all-round players who want consistency rather than aggressive power.
- **Spin**: Good spin, but not extreme. The topsheet grips the ball well, allowing for controlled spin shots and serves, but it’s not as spinny as tensor rubbers.
- **Control**: Very high control. Musa excels in consistency and precision, making it a great rubber for blocking, pushing, and placement shots.
- **Hardness**: Medium sponge (around 45°), similar to Mark V, but the topsheet is designed for better control and consistency in various playing situations.

**Playing Style**:
- Perfect for **all-round players** who focus on control, placement, and consistency. It’s great for players who don’t rely on speed but prefer a slower, more controlled game with good defensive capabilities.

---

### **Comparison & Suitability for All-Round Players**

- **Speed**:
- **Donic Coppa** > **Yasaka Mark V** > **Xiom Musa**.
- If you want more speed and aggression, Donic Coppa is the best choice. Yasaka Mark V offers a good balance, while Xiom Musa is slower but more controlled.

- **Spin**:
- **Donic Coppa** ≈ **Yasaka Mark V** > **Xiom Musa**.
- Donic Coppa and Mark V both offer good spin, but Mark V has better control over spins. Xiom Musa, while not as spinny, provides reliable spin with excellent control.

- **Control**:
- **Xiom Musa** > **Yasaka Mark V** > **Donic Coppa**.
- Xiom Musa excels in control, making it the best option for consistent play. Mark V also offers great control, while Donic Coppa is less forgiving due to its speed.

### **Which is Most Suitable for All-Round Players?**

For a classic all-round player, **Yasaka Mark V** is likely the best choice because of its perfect balance of speed, spin, and control. It’s versatile enough to handle both offense and defense effectively, making it ideal for all-round play.

- If you want **more control and consistency** (with slightly less speed), **Xiom Musa** is a great option.
- If you are an all-round player looking to transition to a **more offensive game**, **Donic Coppa** offers more speed and spin but with slightly less control.

In conclusion:
- **Yasaka Mark V**: Best balance for all-round players.
- **Xiom Musa**: For control-oriented all-rounders.
- **Donic Coppa**: For offensive all-round players.